The Quantellect read.As of Nov 19, 2026, 3 active firms cover American Integrity Insurance Group, Inc: 3 rate it Buy or better, 0 sit at Neutral, and 0 rate it Sell or worse, a buy consensus. Targets are tightly clustered, $26.00 to $31.00, so the covering firms are broadly aligned. The average target of $28.67 sits 3% below the current $29.58. The rating mix has stayed broadly stable, with Buy-side ratings easing from 5 to 3 over recent months. On the fundamentals, the Street sees revenue growth near 36% this year and 17% next, consensus EPS building from about $1.24 next quarter toward $3.56 the year after.Descriptive synthesis of third-party analyst data, not a Quantellect rating or recommendation.
ANALYST CONSENSUS3 active firms
Buy
Strong Buy00%
Buy3100%
Neutral00%
Sell00%
Strong Sell00%
Based on 3 active firms as of Nov 19, 2026 (365-day activity window).
12-MONTH PRICE TARGET
$28.67
-3.1% downside
Average target across 3 active firms as of Nov 19, 2026 vs $29.58 current
Highest Target$31.00
Average Target$28.67
Lowest Target$26.00
Detailed analyst forecasts for AII
Showing 1–4 of 4 named analysts shown · 3 active firms in the rating projection
As of Nov 19, 2026, 3 of 3 active firms rate AII a Buy (0 Neutral, 0 Sell). Historical months are month-end active-firm counts; the current month uses its actual as-of date.
AII EPS & revenue forecast
EPS · NEXT QUARTER
$1.24
Range $1.05 – $1.38 · 6 analysts · +11% YoY
Next period, 6 analysts expect American Integrity Insurance Group, Inc. to earn $1.24 a share (range $1.05 – $1.38), versus $1.11 a year earlier. Full-year consensus is $4.42, growing to $3.56 the year after.
REVENUE · NEXT QUARTER
$130.6M
Range $123.2M – $138.0M · 6 analysts · +52% YoY
Revenue is expected to reach $130.6M (range $123.2M – $138.0M), +52.0% year-over-year. Full-year consensus is $431.5M, rising to $531.8M next year.
Top analysts covering American Integrity Insurance Group, Inc.
Ranked by each analyst's overall Quantellect track record across all the stocks they cover, shown with their current call on AII.
#1
C. Gregory Peters
Raymond James · Rank #240
Buy
$24.00-18.9% to target
Overall win rate
52%
+ Follow
#2
Paul Newsome
Piper Sandler · Rank #272
Buy
$26.00-12.1% to target
Overall win rate
50%
+ Follow
#3
TM
Thomas McJoynt-Griffith
Keefe, Bruyette & Woods · Rank #304
Buy
$26.00-12.1% to target
Overall win rate
47%
+ Follow
#4
Matthew J. Carletti
JMP Securities · Rank #368
Buy
$23.00-22.2% to target
Overall win rate
44%
+ Follow
#5
TM
Tommy McJoynt
Keefe, Bruyette & Woods
Buy
$31.00+4.8% to target
Coverage
—
+ Follow
AII stock forecast FAQ
What is AII's average 12-month price target?+
The 3 active firms with a live target average $28.67 for American Integrity Insurance Group, Inc. over the next 12 months, ranging from a $31.00 high to a $26.00 low, as of Nov 19, 2026.
Is AII stock a Buy, Sell or Neutral right now?+
The current consensus is Buy. Of the 3 active firms as of Nov 19, 2026, 3 rate it Buy or Strong Buy, 0 rate it Neutral, and 0 rate it Sell or Strong Sell.
What are the highest and lowest price targets for AII?+
The Street-high target is $31.00 (Keefe, Bruyette & Woods), and the Street-low is $26.00 (Piper Sandler). The average of all 3 active-firm targets is $28.67.
How many active Wall Street firms cover AII?+
3 active firms have a recognized rating on American Integrity Insurance Group, Inc. as of Nov 19, 2026, and 3 active firms carry a live 12-month price target.
Who is the most accurate analyst covering AII?+
Among analysts who currently cover AII, C. Gregory Peters of Raymond James has the strongest overall Quantellect track record (Rank #240). Their current call is Buy with a $24.00 target.
What is American Integrity Insurance Group, Inc.'s projected EPS for next quarter?+
The consensus estimate is $1.24 per share (range $1.05 – $1.38) across 6 analysts. Full-year EPS is projected at $4.42, rising to $3.56 the following year.
How much revenue is American Integrity Insurance Group, Inc. expected to report next quarter?+
Consensus revenue is $130.6M (range $123.2M – $138.0M). Full-year revenue is projected at $431.5M, growing to $531.8M next year.
Have analysts been upgrading or downgrading AII lately?+
As of Nov 19, 2026, 3 of 3 active firms rate AII a Buy (0 Neutral, 0 Sell). Historical months are month-end active-firm counts; the current month uses its actual as-of date.
How are the analysts on this page ranked?+
By each analyst's overall Quantellect track record — a sample-adjusted measure of how accurate their calls have been across every stock they cover. We do not rank on their AII calls alone, since a single stock is too small a sample to be reliable.
Which data on this page is live, and how often does it update?+
Price and daily change are 15-minute delayed market data. Analyst ratings, targets, consensus and earnings estimates are aggregated from multiple data providers and refresh daily.
Disclaimer: Ratings, price targets, consensus and earnings estimates on this page describe third-party analyst research aggregated from multiple data providers and refreshed daily; price and daily change are 15-minute delayed. These are historical opinions, not recommendations, and nothing on this page, including The Quantellect read, is a rating, a price target, or investment advice from Quantellect. Always do your own research and consult a licensed financial advisor before making investment decisions.