The Quantellect read.As of Nov 19, 2026, 7 active firms cover Selective Insurance Group, Inc: 2 rate it Buy or better, 4 sit at Neutral, and 1 rate it Sell or worse, a neutral consensus. Targets span $80.00 to $115.00, a moderate spread. The average target of $99.33 sits 4% below the current $103.70. The rating mix has held broadly steady over recent months. On the fundamentals, the Street sees consensus EPS building from about $2.20 next quarter toward $9.05 the year after.Descriptive synthesis of third-party analyst data, not a Quantellect rating or recommendation.
ANALYST CONSENSUS7 active firms
Neutral
Strong Buy00%
Buy229%
Neutral457%
Sell114%
Strong Sell00%
Based on 7 active firms as of Nov 19, 2026 (365-day activity window).
12-MONTH PRICE TARGET
$99.33
-4.2% downside
Average target across 6 active firms as of Nov 19, 2026 vs $103.70 current
Highest Target$115.00
Average Target$99.33
Lowest Target$80.00
Detailed analyst forecasts for SIGI
Showing 1–6 of 6 named analysts shown · 7 active firms in the rating projection
As of Nov 19, 2026, 2 of 7 active firms rate SIGI a Buy (4 Neutral, 1 Sell). Historical months are month-end active-firm counts; the current month uses its actual as-of date.
SIGI EPS & revenue forecast
EPS · NEXT QUARTER
$2.20
Range $2.01 – $2.29 · 7 analysts · +30% YoY
Next period, 7 analysts expect Selective Insurance Group, Inc. to earn $2.20 a share (range $2.01 – $2.29), versus $1.69 a year earlier. Full-year consensus is $8.73, growing to $9.05 the year after.
REVENUE · NEXT QUARTER
$1.3B
Range $1.3B – $1.4B · 7 analysts · -2% YoY
Revenue is expected to reach $1.3B (range $1.3B – $1.4B), -2.3% year-over-year. Full-year consensus is $5.4B, rising to $5.3B next year.
Top analysts covering Selective Insurance Group, Inc.
Ranked by each analyst's overall Quantellect track record across all the stocks they cover, shown with their current call on SIGI.
#1
Meyer Shields
Keefe, Bruyette & Woods · Rank #259
Neutral
$102.00-1.6% to target
Overall win rate
44%
+ Follow
#2
Paul Newsome
Piper Sandler · Rank #272
Neutral
$97.00-6.5% to target
Overall win rate
50%
+ Follow
#3
Rowland Mayor
RBC Capital
Buy
$115.00+10.9% to target
Coverage
—
+ Follow
#4
BH
Bob Huang
Morgan Stanley
Sell
$80.00-22.9% to target
Coverage
—
+ Follow
#5
Michael Zaremski
BMO Capital
Neutral
$98.00-5.5% to target
Coverage
—
+ Follow
SIGI stock forecast FAQ
What is SIGI's average 12-month price target?+
The 6 active firms with a live target average $99.33 for Selective Insurance Group, Inc. over the next 12 months, ranging from a $115.00 high to a $80.00 low, as of Nov 19, 2026.
Is SIGI stock a Buy, Sell or Neutral right now?+
The current consensus is Neutral. Of the 7 active firms as of Nov 19, 2026, 2 rate it Buy or Strong Buy, 4 rate it Neutral, and 1 rate it Sell or Strong Sell.
What are the highest and lowest price targets for SIGI?+
The Street-high target is $115.00 (RBC Capital), and the Street-low is $80.00 (Morgan Stanley). The average of all 6 active-firm targets is $99.33.
How many active Wall Street firms cover SIGI?+
7 active firms have a recognized rating on Selective Insurance Group, Inc. as of Nov 19, 2026, and 6 active firms carry a live 12-month price target.
Who is the most accurate analyst covering SIGI?+
Among analysts who currently cover SIGI, Meyer Shields of Keefe, Bruyette & Woods has the strongest overall Quantellect track record (Rank #259). Their current call is Neutral with a $102.00 target.
What is Selective Insurance Group, Inc.'s projected EPS for next quarter?+
The consensus estimate is $2.20 per share (range $2.01 – $2.29) across 7 analysts. Full-year EPS is projected at $8.73, rising to $9.05 the following year.
How much revenue is Selective Insurance Group, Inc. expected to report next quarter?+
Consensus revenue is $1.3B (range $1.3B – $1.4B). Full-year revenue is projected at $5.4B, growing to $5.3B next year.
Have analysts been upgrading or downgrading SIGI lately?+
As of Nov 19, 2026, 2 of 7 active firms rate SIGI a Buy (4 Neutral, 1 Sell). Historical months are month-end active-firm counts; the current month uses its actual as-of date.
How are the analysts on this page ranked?+
By each analyst's overall Quantellect track record — a sample-adjusted measure of how accurate their calls have been across every stock they cover. We do not rank on their SIGI calls alone, since a single stock is too small a sample to be reliable.
Which data on this page is live, and how often does it update?+
Price and daily change are 15-minute delayed market data. Analyst ratings, targets, consensus and earnings estimates are aggregated from multiple data providers and refresh daily.
Disclaimer: Ratings, price targets, consensus and earnings estimates on this page describe third-party analyst research aggregated from multiple data providers and refreshed daily; price and daily change are 15-minute delayed. These are historical opinions, not recommendations, and nothing on this page, including The Quantellect read, is a rating, a price target, or investment advice from Quantellect. Always do your own research and consult a licensed financial advisor before making investment decisions.